Chocolate Protein Powder Showdown: My Honest Review

If you’re like me, you care about what goes into your body—and you want your supplements to actually taste good too. Whether you're a busy mama needing quick nourishment or someone trying to rebuild strength postpartum, protein is one of the most powerful tools in your health toolkit.

I’ve tried so many protein powders over the years, but today I’m comparing four clean chocolate protein powders that I personally use and love: Just Ingredients, Organifi, Paleo Valley, and Equip. Below you’ll find a breakdown of the ingredients, protein content, cost per serving, and of course—how they taste.

Why Is Protein So Important?

Protein isn’t just for bodybuilders. It’s essential for:

• Hormone production (hello postpartum support!)

• Tissue repair (especially after childbirth or intense exercise)

• Blood sugar balance

• Feeling full and satisfied

• Building and maintaining lean muscle

Women—especially busy moms—often under-eat protein, and it shows up in low energy, cravings, mood swings, and hair loss. A good protein powder can help fill the gap on those extra chaotic days.

The Chocolate Protein Powder Lineup

1. Just Ingredients Chocolate Protein Powder

• Protein per serving: 24g

• Protein source: Just Ingredients Chocolate Protein Powder is made with five different protein sources including 100% grass-fed, non-denatured whey protein from New Zealand, Pea Protein, Pumpkin Seed Protein, Grass-Fed Collagen, Chia Seed Protein.

• Other ingredients: Monk fruit, cocoa powder, coconut milk powder, stevia leaf, sea salt ( It's flavored with real food. No natural or artificial flavors, no gums, emulsifiers, artificial sweeteners, or sugar alcohols.)

• Cost: ~$59.99 for 30 servings ($1.99/serving). With my 10% discount code (holisticheidi) it comes out to ~$1.79/serving

• Taste: Creamy and smooth. Tastes like a chocolate milk when blended with milk. I think the coconut milk in it makes it extra cream.

• My take: Super clean and satisfying. No weird aftertaste. Kid-approved! It is seriously so delicious!

• Just Ingredients Discount Code (10% off): holisticheidi

2. Organifi Complete Chocolate Protein

• Protein per serving: 18g

• Protein source: Organifi Complete Chocolate Protein powder uses all organic plant proteins including pea protein, quinoa flour, pumpkin seed protein

• Other ingredients: Digestive enzyme blend, coconut milk, vitamins, and minerals and more whole foods.

• Cost: ~$79.95 for 30 servings ($2.66/serving). With 20% off discount code (holisticheidi) it comes out to $2.13/serving.

• Taste: Earthier and less sweet than others, but still so good.

• My take: Great option if you’re dairy-free or vegan. I love the added digestive support and that it is organic.

• Organifi Discount Code (20% off): holisticheidi

3. Paleo Valley Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder with Colostrum (Chocolate)

• Protein per serving: 13g

• Protein source: Paleo Valley's Protein Powder uses 100% grass-fed whey protein

• Other ingredients: Colostrum, digestive enzymes, organic cacao, coconut milk, monk fruit, tapioca root, acacia fiber, Himalayan salt, organic chocolate flavor.

• Cost: ~$69.99 for 30 servings ($2.33/serving). My link takes 15% off at checkout bringing it down to $59.49 a bag which is $1.98/serving.

• Taste: Creamy chocolate flavor. This one is my kids favorite one!

• My take: As far as tastes goes it is one of my favorites. I love that it also has colostrum in it for added immune and gut support as well as digestive enzymes. I do wish it had more protein per serving though, but if your looking for protein powder with the added benefit of immune support and gut support then this is it!

• Paleo Valley Discount Code (15% off) - my link will automatically take 15% off at checkout.

4. Equip Prime Protein (Chocolate)

• Protein per serving: 21g

• Protein source: Equip Prime Protein uses grass-fed beef isolate protein

• Other ingredients: Cocoa powder, stevia (It is literally 3 ingredients in their chocolate protein powder!)

• Cost: ~$63.99 for 30 servings ($2.13/serving). With my 15% off link it brings it down to $54.39 which is $1.81/serving

• Taste: Surprisingly smooth and chocolatey! Not beefy at all.

• My take: If your looking for incredibly bioavailable protein from grass fed beef with very few ingredients then this is it! As far as taste goes I prefer the other ones but this one is still good!

• Equip Prime Protein Discount Code (15% off): holisticheidi (or use this link and it will automatically take the 15% off at checkout)

My Top Pick?

Honestly, they’re all solid options depending on your needs. If I had to pick:

• Best taste: Just Ingredients or Paleo Valley

• Best for gut health: Paleo Valley (added colostrum and digestive enzymes) or Organifi (added digestive enzymes)

• Best dairy-free option: Equip or Organifi

• Best all-in-one (vitamins + protein + digestive enzymes): Organifi

• Best all-in-one with immune support: Paleo Valley since it has the added colostrum

Final Thoughts

A clean protein powder is one of the easiest ways to support your energy, hormones, and healing—especially when you’re short on time (like every mom ever). Just add it to a glass of water or milk, smoothie, oatmeal, or protein balls for a quick boost!

Note: this blog does contain affiliate links so I may earn a small commission or product credit if you choose to use my links. By no means feel obligated to use them! I only share what I love in hopes you will love it to!